
Parameter: λ12 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
σ11λ12-σ12
Single Door Criterion:
{1} ⊥ {2,4} | {}
Parameter: λ23 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
σ12σ14λ23-σ13σ14-σ11σ24λ23+σ11σ34,
σ122λ23-σ12σ13-σ11σ22λ23+σ11σ23
Single Door Criterion:
{2} ⊥ {3} | {1}
{2} ⊥ {3} | {1,4}
Instrumental Variable:
4 | {1}
Parameter: λ24 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
σ23λ24-σ34,
σ22λ24-σ24,
σ12λ24-σ14
Single Door Criterion:
{2} ⊥ {4} | {}
{2} ⊥ {4} | {3}
{2} ⊥ {4} | {1}
{2} ⊥ {4} | {1,3}
Instrumental Variable:
1 | {}
1 | {3}
3 | {}
3 | {1}
Parameter: ω11 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
-σ11+ω11
Parameter: ω13 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
σ11σ13σ24-σ11σ12σ34+σ12σ14ω13-σ11σ24ω13,
σ11σ13σ22-σ11σ12σ23+σ122ω13-σ11σ22ω13
Parameter: ω22 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
σ122-σ11σ22+σ11ω22
Parameter: ω33 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
-σ12σ132σ14σ24-σ122σ142σ33+2σ11σ12σ14σ24σ33-σ112σ242σ33+2σ122σ13σ14σ34-2σ11σ122σ342+σ112σ22σ342+σ122σ142ω33-2σ11σ12σ14σ24ω33+σ112σ242ω33,
-σ122σ132σ24-σ123σ14σ33+2σ11σ122σ24σ33-σ112σ22σ24σ33+2σ123σ13σ34-2σ11σ122σ23σ34+σ112σ22σ23σ34+σ123σ14ω33-2σ11σ122σ24ω33+σ112σ22σ24ω33,
-σ122σ132σ22+2σ123σ13σ23-2σ11σ122σ232+σ112σ22σ232-σ124σ33+2σ11σ122σ22σ33-σ112σ222σ33+σ124ω33-2σ11σ122σ22ω33+σ112σ222ω33
Parameter: ω44 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
σ24σ34-σ23σ44+σ23ω44,
σ242-σ22σ44+σ22ω44,
σ14σ24-σ12σ44+σ12ω44
Total Effect of X1 on X3: λ12λ23 Identified
Each Parameter Identified
Total Effect of X1 on X4: λ12λ24 Identified
Each Parameter Identified
Back Door Criterion:
{1} ⊥ {2,4} | {}
Constraint Set:
σ23σ24-σ22σ34,
σ14σ23-σ12σ34,
σ14σ22-σ12σ24
All constraints are determinantal
Trek-separation:
{1,2,3} ⊥ {2,4} | ({},{2})
{2,1,3} ⊥ {1,2,4} | ({2},{1})
{1,2,3} ⊥ {2,3,4} | ({},{2,3})
{1,2,3} ⊥ {1,2,4} | ({},{1,2})
Algebraic Equations:
σ11λ12-σ12
Single Door Criterion:
{1} ⊥ {2,4} | {}
Parameter: λ23 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
σ12σ14λ23-σ13σ14-σ11σ24λ23+σ11σ34,
σ122λ23-σ12σ13-σ11σ22λ23+σ11σ23
Single Door Criterion:
{2} ⊥ {3} | {1}
{2} ⊥ {3} | {1,4}
Instrumental Variable:
4 | {1}
Parameter: λ24 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
σ23λ24-σ34,
σ22λ24-σ24,
σ12λ24-σ14
Single Door Criterion:
{2} ⊥ {4} | {}
{2} ⊥ {4} | {3}
{2} ⊥ {4} | {1}
{2} ⊥ {4} | {1,3}
Instrumental Variable:
1 | {}
1 | {3}
3 | {}
3 | {1}
Parameter: ω11 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
-σ11+ω11
Parameter: ω13 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
σ11σ13σ24-σ11σ12σ34+σ12σ14ω13-σ11σ24ω13,
σ11σ13σ22-σ11σ12σ23+σ122ω13-σ11σ22ω13
Parameter: ω22 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
σ122-σ11σ22+σ11ω22
Parameter: ω33 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
-σ12σ132σ14σ24-σ122σ142σ33+2σ11σ12σ14σ24σ33-σ112σ242σ33+2σ122σ13σ14σ34-2σ11σ122σ342+σ112σ22σ342+σ122σ142ω33-2σ11σ12σ14σ24ω33+σ112σ242ω33,
-σ122σ132σ24-σ123σ14σ33+2σ11σ122σ24σ33-σ112σ22σ24σ33+2σ123σ13σ34-2σ11σ122σ23σ34+σ112σ22σ23σ34+σ123σ14ω33-2σ11σ122σ24ω33+σ112σ22σ24ω33,
-σ122σ132σ22+2σ123σ13σ23-2σ11σ122σ232+σ112σ22σ232-σ124σ33+2σ11σ122σ22σ33-σ112σ222σ33+σ124ω33-2σ11σ122σ22ω33+σ112σ222ω33
Parameter: ω44 Identified
Algebraic Equations:
σ24σ34-σ23σ44+σ23ω44,
σ242-σ22σ44+σ22ω44,
σ14σ24-σ12σ44+σ12ω44
Total Effect of X1 on X3: λ12λ23 Identified
Each Parameter Identified
Total Effect of X1 on X4: λ12λ24 Identified
Each Parameter Identified
Back Door Criterion:
{1} ⊥ {2,4} | {}
Vanishing Ideal
Constraint Set:
σ23σ24-σ22σ34,
σ14σ23-σ12σ34,
σ14σ22-σ12σ24
All constraints are determinantal
Trek-separation:
{1,2,3} ⊥ {2,4} | ({},{2})
{2,1,3} ⊥ {1,2,4} | ({2},{1})
{1,2,3} ⊥ {2,3,4} | ({},{2,3})
{1,2,3} ⊥ {1,2,4} | ({},{1,2})