Sept. 22nd
 

[Chelsea]
Weather: sunny, hot, windy, temperature in mid 80's
Working time: 6:30 am-12:00 pm 12:30 pm - 4:00 pm

[Becky]
Today we got up really early and were out…by 5:30. We headed over to Holly House part of Hovenweep, to watch the sunrise on the equinox. There are three spirals pecked into the rock there that are lit up w/ sunrise on the equinox. Even though it was mostly cloudy, the sun peeked through for long enough for us to tell that the sun beam first cast a line of light right along the bottom of one of the spirals, and then moved so that there was a right angle corner of light centered on one spiral, and the light continued down to just brush the bottom of the 3rd spiral. There were a lot of petroglyphs there, including snakes, and two twins (or one set of twins). After watching the beautiful sunrise, we toured Holly House-finding all the masonry hidden away in the little nooks and crannys.

[Katie]
After Holly House, we went to Cutthroat Castle. It was pretty amazing. The main tower was really cool. It was pretty difficult to enter. You had to enter on the cliff edge or through a small tunnel on the bottom. It seemed pretty obvious that the tower was used defensively just because it was so difficult to enter. It makes you wonder what the other towers were used for. Were they defensive? Why did they build all these towers in hard to reach places? They can't all be for line-of-site cause not all of them have such great views, like Lightning Tree Tower, for example. You can't see much but trees. However, one thing that is noticeable is that you can see the other towers [at Cutthroat Castle] from almost every other tower [at Cutthroat]. That makes me lean a bit more towards these towers having a defensive nature. It makes me think of the Great Wall of China. If one outpost on the wall got attacked, it could be seen by another one and fire was lit to notify the other outpost towers that something was up. Maybe they didn't want their towers to be super obvious and observable from long distances so they could be more protected?

A wooden bridge completing the foundation of a roomblock on separate boulders at Cutthroat Castle Cutthroat Castle itself. Cutthroat Castle viewed between the ever-increasing gap between two multi-story roomblocks.
   
  Masonry walls at Cutthroat Castle.  

After we left Cutthroat Castle, we finally went to Painted Hand. Painted Hand was surveyed on another field trip by CC students a few years ago. There were pictographs of hands at this site (hence the name). Some are negative handprints (paint sprayed on the rock) and some were painted hand prints…There were lots of dwellings in rock crevices, both habitation sites and storage sites. There were lots of kivas scattered throughout the area and there was a possible reservoir. The reservoir looked as though there had been three separate constructions. One was older, possibly PI because it had upright slabs, then a PII/PIII remodeling because it had McElmo-ish style architecture and maybe a later one with huge rocks which would have taken a couple of men to move. I'm not sure if the larger boulders were later than the PII/PIII remodelings, but it might have been Navajo? Anyway, it was obviously used during at least three different time periods. I'm pretty sure I'm convinced it was used to hold water because if they had had some more architecture remaining, if it had been an open plaza type thing, it would have filled with water. So that was pretty interesting.

At Painted Hand there were also some cool petroglyphs of some turkey foot prints. I wonder what that was for? There were facing the inside of a rock crevice, so they weren't pointing to a specific place on the landscape. Maybe they were pointing to a place someone should sit to observe something, or maybe showing where they, or something, had come from? It would be interesting to research that specific petroglyph, it is very intriguing.

There was a site a site that was on top of the mesa that was smaller. I think it had one kiva and a few roomblocks. Ruth suggested that it was a place for people to stay while they farmed on the mesa top, which seems to make sense. Also, it could have been used to watch over the crops, possibly from people who wanted to steal the crops?

The valley below the Painted Hand tower site. Don't look now, there's a roomblock hiding down there. Becky, Tucker, and Trevor exploring a roomblock on top of a boulder. The only way up is via a juniper. Painted Hand tower, with a small masonry room beneath. The wall has small, negative image handprints.
Painted Hand Tower. The remains of another tower on the boulder in the background. Turkey track petroglyphs at Painted Hand. Wall and viga holes at Painted Hand.
[Chelsea]
In the afternoon we went to Negro Canyon to look at the towers and associated architectural features that are contemporaneous to the towers at Hovenweep and Painted Hand. The towers at Negro Canyon were also situated on large boulders, seemingly in an ideal spot for defense. Also, the towers have excellent line of sight with the Chuskas and even all the way to Monument Valley. Indeed the canyon rim seems like it would have been an ideal spot to maximize intervisibility with other towers. One odd feature at Negro Canyon was the extremely large sandstone blocks used for the masonry walls. Specifically, there was one long wall of large sandstone blocks running along the edge of the canyon rim for tens of meters…As there is a rubble mound that looks like it might be a kiva that is located directly behind this wall it seems like this wall could have part of a D-shaped structure on the edge of the mesa top. This wall may have enclosed a plaza. The high location of this structure atop the canyon seems like an ideal spot for a ceremonial structure as it has great vistas and a dramatic location.

[Tucker]
After Painted Hand we proceeded to Negro Canyon to check out this sweet site at the head of the canyon above a spring. Lots of towers or other masonry structures on top of boulders and a lot of roomblocks on the rim.

Towers:
I no longer believe that isolated towers are for defense. It's very cramped in there, you could not hold enough surplus in there for an extended period of time for many people, and they are isolated. Towers attached to larger roomblocks, maybe defensive, but not isolated towers. It just doesn't make sense.

back to Journal