| City | Alumni |
| Allendale | 1 |
| Asbury | 1 |
| Atlantic Highland | 1 |
| Augusta | 1 |
| Basking Ridge | 3 |
| Bayonne | 1 |
| Belle Mead | 1 |
| Berkeley Heights | 1 |
| Bernardsville | 3 |
| Blackwood | 2 |
| Blairstown | 1 |
| Bloomfield | 1 |
| Boonton Township | 1 |
| Branchville | 1 |
| Brick | 1 |
| Brielle | 2 |
| Burlington | 1 |
| Caldwell | 1 |
| Califon | 1 |
| Camden | 1 |
| Cape May | 1 |
| Cedarville | 1 |
| Chatham | 3 |
| Cherry Hill | 3 |
| Chester | 2 |
| Delran | 1 |
| Denville | 1 |
| E Brunswick | 1 |
| E Rutherford | 1 |
| East Windsor | 1 |
| Edison | 1 |
| Egg Harbor Township | 2 |
| Essex Fells | 3 |
| Ewing | 1 |
| Fanwood | 2 |
| Far Hills | 3 |
| Flanders | 1 |
| Flemington | 2 |
| Fredon | 1 |
| Freehold | 1 |
| Glen Gardner | 2 |
| Glen Ridge | 4 |
| Glen Rock | 3 |
| Hackensack | 2 |
| Haddonfield | 1 |
| Hawthorne | 1 |
| Highland Park | 5 |
| Hightstown | 3 |
| Hillsdale | 1 |
| Hoboken | 3 |
| Jackson | 1 |
| Jersey City | 3 |
| Lafayette | 1 |
| Lakewood | 1 |
| Lambertville | 2 |
| Lincoln Park | 2 |
| Lincroft | 1 |
| Little Silver | 1 |
| Livingston | 2 |
| Long Valley | 3 |
| Madison | 2 |
| Mahwah | 1 |
| Mantoloking | 1 |
| Maplewood | 9 |
| Mendham | 4 |
| Metuchen | 1 |
| Middlesex | 1 |
| Midland Park | 1 |
| Monmouth Junction | 1 |
| Monroe Twp | 1 |
| Montclair | 10 |
| Montville | 1 |
| Morganville | 1 |
| Morristown | 5 |
| Mount Laurel | 3 |
| Neptune | 2 |
| New Vernon | 1 |
| Newark | 2 |
| Oakhurst | 1 |
| Ocean | 1 |
| Ocean City | 1 |
| Oradell | 1 |
| Palmyra | 1 |
| Paramus | 1 |
| Paterson | 1 |
| Pennington | 1 |
| Pompton Plains | 1 |
| Princeton | 17 |
| Princeton Junction | 1 |
| Randolph | 1 |
| Red Bank | 3 |
| Ridgewood | 5 |
| Ringoes | 1 |
| Ringwood | 1 |
| Robbinsville | 1 |
| Roselle | 1 |
| Rumson | 2 |
| Saddle River | 1 |
| Sewell | 1 |
| Short Hills | 4 |
| Shrewsbury | 1 |
| Skillman | 4 |
| Somerville | 2 |
| South Orange | 6 |
| Sparta | 1 |
| Summit | 5 |
| Tenafly | 4 |
| Titusville | 3 |
| Trenton | 3 |
| Twp. of Washington | 1 |
| Union | 1 |
| Upper Montclair | 1 |
| Upper Saddle River | 3 |
| W Orange | 1 |
| Waldwick | 1 |
| Warren | 2 |
| Washington | 1 |
| Watchung | 2 |
| Wayne | 1 |
| Weehawken | 2 |
| West Milford | 1 |
| West New York | 3 |
| West Trenton | 1 |
| Westfield | 3 |
| Westmont | 1 |
| Westwood | 1 |
| Woodlynne | 1 |
| Wyckoff | 3 |